ad

Harold Wilson's failures and successes between 1964-1970

Failures: 

  • Devaluation of the pound - high value of the pound as making exports more expensive but imports cheap. Also could have done it earlier to make it an economic success and save himself from all the drama behind it. 
  • Deflationary methods made supporters distrustful towards Labour. 
  • Tensions with the Unions. 
  • Wilson always believed that people were plotting against him. 
  • Department of Economic Affairs - clashed with the Treasury, National Plan was a failure, George Brown was also a drunk. 
  • Row over "In Place of Strife" 
  • Defence spending was high. 
  • Position of economy was much worse than expected so a lot of promises were broken. 
  • "No British government has disappointed their supporters so thoroughly". 

Successes: 
  • Got a majority vote in the 1966 general election. 
  • Economy actually improved through Roy Jenkin's deflationary methods. 
  • Establishment of Open University in 1969. 
  • The Abortion act was passed. 
  • Abolished the death penalty. 
  • First Comprehensive school was established. 
  • Wilson was a modern man - he captured the mood of the moment by the "white-heat of technology" slogan. 
  • Successful companies were starting out at this time e.g International Computers LMT. 

Harold Wilson's economic problems - 1964-1970

Economic Inheritance 
  • Much worse than conservatives led on - £400 million balance of payments deficit. 
  • Economic growth in the UK was much lower than Japan and other European countries. 

Prices and Incomes Policy 
  • Government intervention to set limits on prices rises and wage restraint. 
  • Caused tensions with the trade unions. 

Department of Economic Affairs
  • Drive for economic expansion. 
  • Overlapped with the Treasury. 
  • Civil servants found it difficult to know which boss they should be listening to. 

George Brown
  • Was the head of the Department of Economic Affairs. 
  • Impulsive and lacked consistency. 
  • Had a drink problem. 
  • Was virtually in competition with Callaghan (the Chancellor). 
  • But was actually an able politician. 

Devaluation 
  • Reduced the exchanage of sterling from $2.80 to $2.40. 
  • Damaged Labour's credibility. 
  • It was theatrical - Wilson told people that the pound was not worth any less when it was. 
  • It was basically an economic failure. 

Trade Union relationship
  • Prices and Incomes policy angered the trade unions. 
  • Strikes began, causing more tensions between government and unions. 



Labour's difficulties in government - 1964-1970

Why did the Labour government find itself in economic difficulties? 

  • Second half of the 20th century was undergoing a major shift in its economic and social structure. 
  • Manufacturing in Britain was shrinking. 
  • Service and finance industries were expanding. 

Why was Britain performing so poorly? 
  • Britain had failed to match the growth rates achieved by the industrial economies of western Europe, Japan and the USA. 
  • Britain also spent too much on defence and therefore very little on industry. 

What was the Department of Economic Affairs? 
  • Led by George Brown. 
  • Its aim was economic expansion. 
  • They drew up the "National Plan" - it aimed to stimulate production and exports by encouraging co-operation between government, employers and trade unions. 
  • Few targets were met so the Plan was quietly disbanded. 

What did Wilson have to do in 1964 and 1967? Who did he blame and why was he worried? 
  • Deficit had grown so much that he had to ask the IMF for a loan in 1967, which he already did in 1964. 
  • He blamed the trade union "trouble makers." 
  • The IMF loan was only a stopgap which was worrying as government was losing control over its own finances. 

What was the "Prices and Incomes policy"? 
  • Policy to keep down inflation. 
  • It set limits on price rises and called for a wage restraint in negotiations between unions and employer.
  • This brought on tensions with the Trade Unions. 

What was Wilson forced to do in 1967? Why did he want to avoid this? 
  • Devaluation of the pound - from $2.80 to $2.40. 
  • Wilson wanted to avoid doing this because he wanted to prove that Labour was not the "party of devaluation". 
  • Instead, he wanted policies for economic growth and to catch up with Britain's international competitors. 
  • His mistake was that he didn't devaluate the pound earlier, so it could have been passed off as a financial adjustment. Delaying it only made it looks like a political and economic failure. 
  • The dramatic way he did this also did not help matters. In his speech, he said the "pound in your pocket was not worth any less" when in fact it was. 

How did Roy Jenkins help Labour's position by 1969-1970?
  • He took over as Chancellor. 
  • Used deflationary methods - raised taxes, tightened up government spending and made improving the balance of payments top priority. 
  • He eventually managed a balance of payments surplus - a key factor for providing the Labour party confidence in winning the 1970 general election. 





Why did Labour win the 1964 general election?


  • Wilson's skilful election campaign. 
  • Lack of spirit for the Conservatives since they were in power for 13 years. 
  • Scandals tainted conservative integrity and competence. 
  • Antiquated system of the Conservative party damaged the attempt at modernisation. 
  • Unemployment reached 800,000 under the Conservative government. 
  • Rejection from the EEC. 
  • Labour party presented a more modern image. 
  • Harold Wilson was more impressive in the public eye. 
  • Satire influence.